Although the children found that the tinfoil was waterproof they decided that it wouldn't be a suitable material for a waterproof jacket as it was too fragile and would break or tear easily. Therefore they concluded that the thin plastic would make the most suitable material for Grace's coat.
We did have a surprise with the felt.......... at first it appeared to be waterproof as the water sat on top of it for over 20 minutes, but as predicted it eventually showed itself to be absorbant and soaked the water up.